The jurisdiction of the centre shall extend to any legal dispute arising. The difference between treaty claims and contract claims 40 c. Convention on the recognition and enforcement of foreign. It entered into force on october 14, 1966, 30 days after ratification by the first 20 states.
A commentary on the convention on the settlement of investment disputes between states and nationals of other states. The definition of investment under the icsid convention. Contracting states and measures taken by them for the. Is the icsid ideologically, structurally, procedurally, or functionally deficient.
Schreuer with loretta malintoppi, august reinisch and anthony sinclair. In the absence of such agreement, the tribunal shall apply the law of the contracting state party to the dispute including its rules on the conflict of laws and such rules of international law as may be applicable. Article 25 of the icsid convention limits arbitral jurisdiction to investment disputes between a contracting state and a national of another contracting state, which is defined as any natural person who had the nationality of a contracting state other than the state party to the dispute on the relevant dates, including the. Are those deficiencies ascribed to the icsid by president raphael correa of ecuador justified and, if so, why. In both cases, the convention follows the traditional definitions of nationality. Chapter ii of the convention, article 25, refers to this topic. International centre for settlement of investment disputes. It discusses how the phrase investment disputes in the conventions title is reflected in the provisions of the icsid convention. Implications of denunciation of the icsid convention 17. In both cases, the convention follows the traditional definitions of. The seat of the centre shall be at the principal office of the. It begins with a discussion of international investment generally as a policy trigger for icsid and, therefore, the greater function served by article 25.
Recent developments in the definition of investment in. Convention on the settlement of investment disputes between states and nationals of other states international centre for settlement of investment disputes submitted to governments by the executive directors of the international bank for reconstruction and development, submitted. Under the law of treaties this argument is set out in article 41 of the vienna convention on the law of treaties vclt, reflecting customary law and therefore applicable to icsid. The other two articles deal with the much narrower questions of excluding other remedies art. It is the first commentary to provide systematic article by article coverage not only of the convention itself, but also of the institution rules, the icsid. This debate was originally triggered by bolivias denunciation of the convention on 2 may 2007. It is the first of three articles in chapter ii, which is headed jurisdiction of the centre. By article 34 of the vienna convention on the law of treaties, a treaty does not create either obligations or rights for a third state without its consent pacta terliis l1ec nocent necprosunt, and it has not been suggested, nor would it be tenable to do so, that article 252b has become a customary rule of international law, recognized as.
The icsid convention is a treaty ratified by 154 contracting states. The key provision is article 25 which speaks of any legal dispute arising directly out of an. Chapter 15 denunciation of the icsid convention and consent. The nationality of juridical persons in international law 1. Are bayindirs treaty claims in reality contract claims. One of the most important features of the icsid convention here. Astorga, the nationality of juridical persons in the icsir convention in light of its jurisprudence 2007 11 max planck unvu 443 c. Splcm 28 december 1964 reprinted in 2 history of the icsid convention n 3 756, 758 intervention of mr ouma uganda. The convention allows these constituent subdivisions or agencies to be parties in icsid proceedings, provided certain procedural requirements are met. On july 5, 2007, the centre received the prescribed lodging fee, and transmitted a copy of the request to the argentine republic.
Jurisdictional requirements under article 25 of the icsid. In both these situations, the investor is protected by article 251 of the convention, which defines jurisdiction and provides that when the parties have given their consent, no party may withdraw its consent unilaterally. I t1hi jurisdictjon of the centre shall extel\llle iwq,egal. Convention on the settlement of investment disputes between. International centre for settlement of investment disputes icsid. The jurisdiction of the centre shall extend to any legal dispute arising directly out of an investment, between a contracting state or any constituent subdivision or agency of a contracting state designated to the centre by that state and a national of another contracting state, which the parties to the dispute consent in writing to submit to the centre. Icsid jurisdiction extends to matters of international investment, but the organizations charter never defines what actually qualfies as an investment. On june 25, 2007, pursuant to article 492 of the icsid convention, the centre received from the claimants a request for rectification andor supplementary decision of the award the request. The tribunal shall decide a dispute in accordance with such rules of law as may be agreed by the parties. Implications of article 72 of the icsid convention in the present.
In the case of icsid, there must be an agreement to arbitrate between the host state and the foreign investor. Investment under article 25 of the icsid convention 33 aa. The secretary of the tribunal, vide letter dated 14 march 2007 and on behalf of the sole arbitrator, had invited both the claimant and the respondent to provide any further written comments on the issue of investment within the. Article 6 of the icsid convention requires the administrative council of icsid to adopt rules of procedure for arbitration and conciliation and for the administrative and financial. See splcm 27 november 1964 reprinted in 2 history of the icsid convention n 3 705, 707 intervention of mr bigay central african republic.
The monograph international centre for settlement of investment disputes icsid is an integral part of intergovernmental organizations in the international encyclopaedia of laws series. What is a qualifying investment under article 25 of the icsid. The matter concerning the effect on the investors consent to arbitration of article 72 has been subject to intense debate in the investment protection area. An introduction to icsid meg kinnear, icsid secretarygeneral. Under the terms of article 71 of the icsid convention this denunciation took effect on january 7, 2010. Article 6 of the icsid convention requires the administrative council of icsid to adopt rules of procedure for arbitration and conciliation and for the administrative and financial regulation of the centre. Participation of african states in the making of the icsid. Article 25 1 the jurisdiction of the centre shall extend to any legal dispute arising directly out of an investment, between a contracting state or any constituent subdivision or agency of a contracting state designated to the centre by that state and a national of another contracting state, which the parties to the dispute consent in writing to. Nationality rules applicable to juridical persons 3. Due to the salini decision, it is unclear whether icsid tribunals apply certain criteria to the assessment investments according to art. Under the terms of article 71 of the icsid convention, this denunciation took effect on november 3, 2007. Does the consent of the contracting parties govern the.
The icsid convention and the regulations and rules adopted pursuant to it are available online and in hard copy in each of the three official languages of the centre english, french and spanish. The jurisdiction of the centre shall extend to any legal dispute arising directly out of an investment between a contracting state. International centre for settlement of investment disputes icsid is an international arbitration institution established in 1966 for legal dispute resolution and conciliation between international investors. Article 25 1 of the icsid convention provides that. On the icsid convention, article 25, and international investment law this part provides background information that is necessary for determining the correct interpretation of article 25. Choosing icsid or uncitral arbitration for investorstate. Nationality of juridical persons in the icsid convention. The icsid is part of and funded by the world bank group, headquartered in washington, d. The provisions of the icsid convention are complemented by regulations and rules adopted by the administrative council of the centre pursuant to article 61ac of the convention. United nations conference on international commercial arbitration, new york, 20 may10 june 1958. Individual hard copies are available from the centre at no charge. Article 251 of the icsid convention legal dispute arising directly out of an investment. Apr 04, 2017 once the denunciation of the icsid convention becomes effective, icsid is no longer an available forum, because the denouncing state ceases to be a contracting party and, therefore, an important condition for icsid jurisdiction under article 251 of the icsid convention is not satisfied. Icsid, icsid convention, investment, article 25, jurisdiction, precedent, interpretation, vclt, vienna convention on the law of treaties, article 31, article 32 8.
642 1189 503 937 1392 412 909 543 517 186 13 1134 1394 1605 608 598 329 1667 1490 128 1412 938 537 1058 818 1471 1011 263 1323 1004 471 63 1301 681